up to 40% off site-wide + free silicone
Top 5 Mistakes People Make When Measuring Their Ring Size
Choosing the right ring size is more than a number on a chart—it's the difference between a ring that feels perfect and one that sits in a drawer because it’s too tight or too loose. Whether you're shopping for a wedding band, engagement ring, or a special gift, the sizing step is one of the most overlooked yet critical parts of the buying process.
At Larson Jewelers, we help thousands of customers find rings that last a lifetime. And while trends and materials may change, one issue always lingers: improper ring sizing. Let’s take a closer look at the five most common mistakes people make when measuring their ring size—and how to avoid them to ensure your ring fits just right.
1. Measuring When Fingers Are Cold or Swollen
Finger size changes throughout the day, depending on body temperature, hydration levels, and even the weather. Cold fingers shrink, while heat or high sodium intake can cause them to swell. Measuring during either of these extremes can easily lead to an inaccurate size.
A ring that fits perfectly in the morning might be uncomfortably tight in the afternoon, and vice versa. For the most consistent sizing, measure your ring finger in the late afternoon or evening, when your body is at its most natural and neutral state.
Avoid measuring right after coming in from outside during winter or after physical activity. Hands should be at room temperature and relaxed for the most accurate result.
2. Relying on Inaccurate or DIY Tools
Using a piece of string or a paper strip may sound easy, but it's one of the least reliable methods for determining ring size. String can stretch. Paper can bend. Neither offers the precision needed for a good fit—especially for rings made of materials that can't be resized, such as tungsten, titanium, or ceramic.
Printable ring size charts found online can also vary in scale depending on how your printer processes the document. A minor misalignment in printing could throw off your measurement by up to a full size.
Instead, opt for a sturdy plastic ring sizer or visit a jeweler to be measured professionally. Most jewelry stores offer this service at no cost, and it only takes a few minutes. If you're ordering online, Larson Jewelers provides reliable ring sizing tools and guidance so you can shop with confidence from home.
3. Measuring Only Once
Your ring size isn't static. It can change depending on the time of day, temperature, and even your salt or alcohol intake the night before. Measuring just once—at a random time—offers only a snapshot, not an accurate average of your actual size.
Take measurements a few different times throughout the day across several days. Aim for consistency. If you're getting results that vary by more than a quarter size, average them out or go with the slightly larger size to ensure comfort, especially if you’re selecting a band that isn’t easily resizable.
People often overlook the importance of repetition, but it's one of the most effective ways to eliminate measurement errors and prevent sizing surprises when your ring arrives.
4. Not Considering the Width of the Band
Many shoppers are surprised to learn that wider bands fit tighter than narrow ones, even if both are labeled the same ring size. A ring that’s 8mm or wider covers more surface area on your finger and naturally feels snugger than a thinner 2mm or 3mm band.
For example, men’s wedding bands are typically wider and require slightly larger sizing than slim engagement bands. This is especially important for materials like tungsten or cobalt chrome, which have less give and can’t be resized.
If you’re switching from a narrow band to a wide one, you may want to size up slightly for comfort. A jeweler can guide you based on the specific width and design of the ring you're choosing.
5. Guessing or Estimating Someone Else’s Size
Trying to guess someone else’s ring size—especially if you're planning a surprise proposal or gift—is understandable but risky. Most people’s fingers differ slightly between hands, and borrowing a ring worn on a different finger won't yield an accurate result.
It’s common for people to estimate based on appearance or use a ring from another finger as a guide, only to discover that the new ring doesn’t fit. And if you’re shopping for rings made from hard-to-resize materials, there may be no easy fix.
If discretion is important, consider subtle ways to get the right size. Borrow a ring your partner wears on the correct hand and finger and bring it to a jeweler to be measured. Or ask a close friend or family member if they know the size. Even better, involve your partner in the process without giving away the full surprise—perhaps by shopping for rings together under the guise of a future event.
Other Factors to Consider When Measuring Ring Size
Beyond the five major mistakes, there are a few more subtle details that can make or break your sizing experience.
-
Finger shape and knuckle size play a role. If your knuckle is much larger than the base of your finger, you’ll need a size that comfortably slides over the knuckle but doesn’t spin at the base. In this case, comfort-fit bands, which are slightly rounded on the inside, can help.
-
Time of year also matters. Fingers tend to swell in the summer and shrink slightly in winter. If you're buying a ring during the colder months but plan to wear it year-round, factor in a slight increase to ensure it remains wearable in warmer weather.
-
Lifestyle choices such as regular physical activity, weight changes, or pregnancy can all affect ring size. If you’re in a transitional stage, consider waiting or choosing a temporary band before committing to a permanent piece.
Can You Resize a Ring After Buying?
Resizing depends heavily on the material of the ring. Gold, silver, and platinum are relatively easy to resize. However, metals like tungsten, titanium, and ceramic are either impossible or extremely difficult to resize due to their hardness and structure.
That’s why getting the sizing right the first time is especially important if you're shopping for alternative metal rings—a popular choice for men's wedding bands due to their durability and modern aesthetic.
At Larson Jewelers, we offer resizing options on many of our rings and even free size exchanges on select collections. Still, avoiding a return or exchange is always more convenient and ensures your special moment isn’t delayed.
How to Know If a Ring Fits Correctly
A ring that fits well should slide over your knuckle with a little resistance and sit comfortably at the base of your finger without pinching. It shouldn’t twist around easily, nor should it leave deep indentations or cut off circulation.
You should need a slight tug to remove the ring, but not a struggle. If the ring falls off when you shake your hand or gets stuck every time you remove it, the sizing likely needs adjustment.
If you’re unsure, consult with a professional jeweler. They can provide a second opinion and help you choose the best fit, particularly if you're between sizes.
Start Your Ring Journey the Right Way
The excitement of buying a ring should never be overshadowed by the frustration of poor sizing. By steering clear of these five common mistakes—measuring in extreme temperatures, using inaccurate tools, measuring just once, ignoring band width, and guessing someone else’s size—you’re setting yourself up for success.
Larson Jewelers is here to guide you every step of the way. With a wide selection of custom bands, durable alternative metals, and expert sizing support, we help you find a ring that’s not just beautiful, but fits perfectly the first time.
Don’t leave something this important up to chance. Measure with confidence. Choose with clarity. Wear with pride.
Find your perfect ring size today with Larson Jewelers and shop with confidence knowing your fit is guaranteed.
Follow on shop