up to 40% off site-wide + free silicone
Natural vs. Lab Diamond Engagement Rings: How to Choose the Perfect Symbol of Your Love
Choosing an engagement ring is more than just picking a piece of jewelry. It's about selecting a symbol of your love story—one that reflects your values, your style, and your shared future. In today’s world, that choice includes deciding between natural diamonds and lab-created diamonds, a decision that’s become increasingly common among modern couples.
This guide from Larson Jewelers explores the key differences between the two options, dispels myths, and helps you confidently choose the diamond that aligns with your heart—and your wallet.
Understanding the Origins: Earth-Made vs. Lab-Made
Natural diamonds have been forming beneath the Earth’s crust for billions of years under immense pressure and heat. They are mined from deep underground and brought to the surface through complex and often expensive processes. These diamonds carry the mystique of geological rarity and centuries of cultural symbolism.
Lab-created diamonds, on the other hand, are grown in controlled environments using advanced technology that replicates the natural diamond-growing process. They are made using either High Pressure High Temperature (HPHT) or Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD) methods. The result? A diamond that is chemically, physically, and optically identical to its natural counterpart—but formed in weeks, not millennia.
While both diamonds may look identical to the naked eye and even under a microscope, the difference lies in their formation, pricing, environmental impact, and perceived value.
Price and Value: Stretching Your Budget Without Compromise
One of the most compelling differences between natural and lab-created diamonds is price. Lab-created diamonds typically cost 30% to 40% less than natural diamonds of the same size and quality. This price difference means that with a lab diamond, couples can often afford a larger carat, better clarity, or more intricate setting without increasing their budget.
Natural diamonds tend to retain value over time better than lab-created ones, and for some buyers, this perceived long-term investment adds appeal. However, resale value for engagement rings in general can vary, and many couples prioritize emotional value and aesthetics over potential future returns.
For couples looking to maximize their budget or invest in a custom design or matching wedding bands, choosing a lab-created diamond can open up more options without compromising brilliance or beauty.
Ethical and Environmental Considerations: Conscious Shopping
Modern shoppers are more conscious than ever about where their products come from—and engagement rings are no exception.
Natural diamond mining, even with regulations in place, can have significant environmental and social impacts. Habitat destruction, carbon emissions, and questionable labor practices have all been concerns historically associated with diamond mining. That said, many mining operations today are certified conflict-free and invest in local communities, environmental rehabilitation, and worker protections.
Lab-grown diamonds are generally considered a more sustainable and ethical alternative. Because they are created in labs, they do not require large-scale excavation or disruption of ecosystems. Additionally, buyers have better traceability and transparency regarding sourcing and production conditions.
For couples who place a high value on sustainability or want a ring they can wear with a clear conscience, lab diamonds offer peace of mind.
Beauty and Brilliance: Can You See the Difference?
When it comes to visual appeal, both natural and lab-created diamonds deliver. They sparkle, reflect light, and hold the timeless allure that diamonds are known for.
Lab-created diamonds undergo the same grading process as natural diamonds, assessed by the 4Cs—cut, color, clarity, and carat weight. In fact, leading gemological institutes like the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) and International Gemological Institute (IGI) certify lab diamonds just as they do with natural ones.
There is no visible difference to the naked eye. Even expert gemologists require specialized tools to distinguish the origin of a diamond. So if your goal is a stunning ring that dazzles on any finger, either choice will deliver.
Emotional and Symbolic Significance
There’s something undeniably romantic about the idea of a diamond formed over billions of years—a stone that has stood the test of time, much like the love it represents. For those who cherish tradition, family heirlooms, or the symbolism of nature, natural diamonds continue to hold a special place.
Conversely, lab-created diamonds represent modern values. They speak to innovation, sustainability, and conscious consumerism. Many couples today see lab-grown diamonds as a symbol of building a future based on integrity, equality, and forward-thinking decisions.
Ultimately, the emotional significance of your engagement ring is defined by you, not the source of the stone.
Common Misconceptions About Lab Diamonds
A few misconceptions still cloud the conversation around lab-created diamonds. It's worth clearing them up:
Lab diamonds are not fake. They are not simulants like cubic zirconia or moissanite. They are real diamonds in every measurable way.
Lab diamonds do not lack beauty or durability. They score a 10 on the Mohs hardness scale, just like natural diamonds.
Lab-created diamonds are not mass-produced with identical results. Each lab diamond, while formed under controlled conditions, has its own unique inclusions and traits.
These misconceptions often stem from the early days of the technology or confusion with imitation stones. Today’s lab-created diamonds are certified, respected, and rapidly growing in popularity across the fine jewelry industry.
What Matters Most in Your Decision
The right diamond for your engagement ring is the one that aligns with your shared values, your lifestyle, and your budget.
You might prefer the natural symbolism and heritage of a mined diamond. You might prioritize sustainability, affordability, and modern ethics with a lab-grown diamond. Both are valid, meaningful choices.
Here are a few things to consider when making your decision:
What story do you want your ring to tell?
How important is sustainability and ethical sourcing to you?
Are you looking to maximize visual impact within your budget?
Is long-term resale value a factor in your decision?
Do you want a ring that aligns with traditional expectations or modern values?
Having a thoughtful conversation about these priorities can help you find common ground and make a confident decision together.
Why Shop With Larson Jewelers
At Larson Jewelers, we believe that your engagement ring should reflect who you are—not just in style, but in substance. That’s why we offer both certified natural diamonds and lab-created diamonds, so you can choose with confidence.
Our team is here to guide you with transparent information, personalized support, and a commitment to craftsmanship. Whether you're browsing online or seeking a custom design, we provide:
A carefully curated selection of conflict-free natural and lab-created diamonds
Engagement rings crafted to last a lifetime, in every setting and metal type
Straightforward pricing and grading so you know exactly what you’re getting
Custom design services for a ring as unique as your relationship
Every ring we sell carries the same commitment to quality, regardless of the diamond’s origin. Because in the end, your love story is what gives the diamond its true sparkle.
Explore Ethical Engagement Rings That Reflect Your Values
If you’re ready to take the next step toward forever, let Larson Jewelers help you find the engagement ring that feels right in every way—visually, ethically, and emotionally.
Explore our full collection of ethical engagement rings today and choose a diamond that’s as thoughtful and intentional as your commitment.
Follow on shop